Chennai HQ · serving India, UAE, Saudi Arabia and Omaninfo@projectassure.inCall us 24/7 +91 94895 88922
Project Assure
Schedule Quality

Earned value management for construction schedules: PV, EV, AC, SPI and CPI explained

Earned value compares planned value, earned value and actual cost to show whether a project is behind the programme, over budget, or both. Here are the formulas, a worked example and the limits of SPI.

In short

Earned value management compares planned value (PV), earned value (EV) and actual cost (AC) at the data date: SV = EV - PV, CV = EV - AC, SPI = EV / PV and CPI = EV / AC, with values below 1.0 unfavourable. One common forecast is EAC = BAC / CPI. SPI drifts back to 1.0 as a late project nears completion, so judge delay from the critical path or earned schedule, not SPI alone.

Earned value management (EVM) in construction measures performance by comparing three numbers at the data date: planned value (PV), earned value (EV) and actual cost (AC). From them you get the schedule performance index, SPI = EV / PV, and the cost performance index, CPI = EV / AC, where a value below 1.0 is unfavourable.

EVM is useful because it ties scope, schedule and cost together. It shows not only whether money has been spent, but whether the work that money was meant to buy has been done.

What is earned value management in construction?

EVM is a project control technique that measures progress against a time-phased budget baseline. It answers three questions: where should we be, where are we actually, and what has it cost? The answers come from three basic measures:

  • Planned value (PV), also called BCWS (budgeted cost of work scheduled): the budgeted cost of the work scheduled to be complete by the data date.
  • Earned value (EV), also called BCWP (budgeted cost of work performed): the budgeted cost of the work actually complete by the data date.
  • Actual cost (AC), also called ACWP (actual cost of work performed): the cost actually incurred for the work complete by the data date.

Two further terms are needed for forecasting. Budget at completion (BAC) is the total baseline budget. Estimate at completion (EAC) is the forecast total cost.

What are the planned value, earned value and actual cost formulas?

PV comes from the baseline: the cumulative budget of the work scheduled up to the data date. EV is the budget of each activity multiplied by its measured percent complete, summed across the project. AC comes from the cost system: invoices, timesheets and accruals for the work done. Everything else in EVM is calculated from these three values and BAC.

MeasureFormulaHow to read it
Schedule variance (SV)SV = EV - PVNegative means less work done than planned
Cost variance (CV)CV = EV - ACNegative means the work done cost more than its budget
Schedule performance index (SPI)SPI = EV / PVBelow 1.0 is behind the programme, above 1.0 is ahead
Cost performance index (CPI)CPI = EV / ACBelow 1.0 is over budget, above 1.0 is under budget
Estimate at completion (EAC)EAC = BAC / CPI (one common method)Forecast final cost if current cost efficiency continues
Estimate to complete (ETC)ETC = EAC - ACForecast cost of the remaining work
Variance at completion (VAC)VAC = BAC - EACNegative means a forecast overrun
To-complete performance index (TCPI)TCPI = (BAC - EV) / (BAC - AC)Cost efficiency needed on the remaining work to finish on budget

What is the schedule performance index (SPI)?

SPI = EV / PV. It is the ratio of work achieved to work planned, both measured in budget terms. An SPI of 0.90 means 90% of the planned work, by value, has been done. An SPI above 1.0 means more work has been done than planned.

SPI measures schedule efficiency in money terms, not in time. An SPI of 0.80 does not mean the project is 20% late in time. Delay to the completion date depends on which activities are behind and whether they are on the critical path, which only the schedule itself can show.

Why does SPI become unreliable near completion?

SPI has a known weakness late in a project. As the work finishes, EV rises towards BAC, and once the planned finish date passes, PV is already equal to BAC. At completion EV equals PV, so SPI returns to 1.0 even if the project finished months late. In the later part of a late project, SPI drifts back towards 1.0 and stops being a useful warning.

Earned schedule is the usual remedy. It finds the earned schedule (ES), the date at which the baseline planned to achieve the EV you have now, and compares it with the actual time elapsed (AT): SPI(t) = ES / AT. Because it is measured in time, SPI(t) keeps showing a late project as late right up to completion.

What is the cost performance index (CPI)?

CPI = EV / AC. A CPI below 1.0 means the work done has cost more than it was budgeted to cost. A CPI of 0.85 means each unit of currency spent has produced 0.85 of budgeted value. A CPI above 1.0 means the work is costing less than budgeted. On most projects the cumulative CPI tends to stabilise once a meaningful share of the work is done, which is why it is widely used for forecasting.

How do you forecast the estimate at completion (EAC)?

One common method is EAC = BAC / CPI. It assumes the cost efficiency achieved so far will continue for the rest of the project. If CPI is 0.80, EAC = BAC / 0.80 = 1.25 × BAC, a forecast overrun of 25% of the budget.

Other standard methods suit different assumptions:

  • EAC = AC + (BAC - EV): the remaining work will be done at the budgeted rate. Use it only when the cause of past variance is clearly one-off.
  • EAC = AC + (BAC - EV) / (CPI × SPI): both cost and schedule performance will affect the remaining work, for example where delay is driving prolongation cost.
  • EAC = AC + a bottom-up estimate to complete: the remaining work is re-estimated from scratch, which is the most robust approach when the original budget no longer reflects the work.

The TCPI shows how realistic the budget still is. If the TCPI is well above the CPI achieved to date, finishing on budget requires a large improvement in cost efficiency that the project has not yet shown.

A worked example (illustrative figures)

The figures below are round numbers chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not from a real project.

A project has a budget at completion (BAC) of 10,000,000. At the month 5 data date, the baseline planned 4,000,000 of work (PV), the work actually complete is worth 3,200,000 at budget rates (EV), and the cost recorded for that work is 4,000,000 (AC).

MeasureCalculationResult
Schedule variance (SV)3,200,000 - 4,000,000-800,000
Cost variance (CV)3,200,000 - 4,000,000-800,000
SPI3,200,000 / 4,000,0000.80
CPI3,200,000 / 4,000,0000.80
EAC (BAC / CPI)10,000,000 / 0.8012,500,000
ETC (EAC - AC)12,500,000 - 4,000,0008,500,000
VAC (BAC - EAC)10,000,000 - 12,500,000-2,500,000
TCPI(10,000,000 - 3,200,000) / (10,000,000 - 4,000,000)1.13

The project has done 80% of the work it planned and is getting 0.80 of value for each unit spent. If that efficiency continues, it will finish about 2,500,000 over budget. To finish on budget instead, it would need a CPI of 1.13 on all remaining work, a big improvement on the 0.80 achieved so far. The schedule itself, not the SPI, must then be checked to see whether the behind-plan work is on the critical path.

How do you read SPI and CPI together?

ResultWhat it meansTypical response
SPI above 1.0, CPI above 1.0Ahead of the programme and under budgetConfirm the progress is real, then maintain
SPI below 1.0, CPI above 1.0Behind the programme but efficient on costLook at adding resources or resequencing, if the budget allows
SPI above 1.0, CPI below 1.0Ahead of the programme but over budgetCheck whether acceleration is costing more than it is worth
SPI below 1.0, CPI below 1.0Behind the programme and over budgetCorrective action and a reforecast of EAC are needed now

How do you get EVM data from a Primavera P6 schedule?

P6 calculates PV, EV and AC when the schedule is cost loaded or resource loaded and a baseline is assigned. A practical sequence:

  1. Load the schedule with budgeted cost or units through resource assignments or expenses. Resource loading in P6 explains how.
  2. Assign the baseline that represents the agreed programme, so PV is calculated from the right dates and budgets.
  3. Set the earned value technique, for example physical percent complete or weighted steps, so EV reflects measured progress rather than elapsed time.
  4. Update progress and actual costs at each data date.
  5. Export time-phased values from the Activity Usage or Resource Usage Spreadsheet, or report the EV columns, to build the S-curve and calculate the indices.

Plotted over time, cumulative PV, EV and AC form the three S-curves used to present EVM results.

What are the common pitfalls in construction EVM?

  • Measuring percent complete by duration rather than physical progress. Half the duration elapsed does not mean half the work is done. Use measured quantities, weighted steps or milestones, or rules such as 0/100 or 50/50 for short activities.
  • Weak baseline control. EVM only works against a stable, agreed baseline. Bring approved changes in through change control, but avoid frequent rebaselining, which wipes out trend analysis.
  • Late or incomplete actual costs. AC must include accruals for work done but not yet invoiced. Otherwise CPI looks better than it is.
  • Treating SPI as a time measure. SPI is a ratio of value, not of days. Use the critical path, and earned schedule where needed, to judge delay to completion.
  • Trusting SPI late in the project. SPI converges to 1.0 at completion whether the project is late or not.

EVM is not just for cost engineers. Planners who understand PV, EV, AC, SPI, CPI and EAC can spot adverse trends early and give project managers a common language for performance. It depends on a loaded baseline, honest progress measurement and timely cost data, which is what our project controls and EVM service sets up and maintains on live programmes.

FAQ

Common questions

What is the difference between planned value and earned value?
Planned value (PV) is the budgeted cost of the work scheduled to be complete by the data date. Earned value (EV) is the budgeted cost of the work actually complete by that date. PV says where the project should be and EV says where it is.
How do you calculate SPI and CPI?
The schedule performance index is SPI = EV / PV and the cost performance index is CPI = EV / AC. For both, a value above 1.0 is favourable and a value below 1.0 is unfavourable.
Why does SPI go back to 1.0 at the end of a late project?
At completion, earned value equals the budget at completion and so does planned value, so SPI = EV / PV becomes 1.0 however late the project finished. Earned schedule, SPI(t) = ES / AT, measures performance in time and avoids this problem.
How is estimate at completion (EAC) calculated?
One common method is EAC = BAC / CPI, which assumes current cost efficiency continues. Other methods include EAC = AC + (BAC - EV) for one-off variances, EAC = AC + (BAC - EV) / (CPI x SPI), and AC plus a bottom-up estimate to complete.
Can I use EVM with a Primavera P6 schedule?
Yes. P6 calculates planned value, earned value and actual cost when the schedule is cost loaded or resource loaded, a baseline is assigned and progress and actuals are updated at each data date.
Chennai city skyline at dusk under a vivid pink and violet sky

Bring this discipline onto your programme.

Every insight comes from live mandates. A principal replies within one working day.